Skip to content

Narrow screen resolution Wide screen resolution Auto adjust screen size Increase font size Decrease font size Default font size default color brick color green color
B.C Tribunal orders halt :AirBnB" guests" NOT RESIDENTIAL TENANCIES but COMMERCIAL LODGERS - JIWA 2020/07/19 20:07  
Not legal advice of course

A B.C. adjudicator issues injunction empowered by s 123 of B.C.’s Civil Resolution Tribunal Act, SBC 2012, c 25 finding that Jiwa group/ Jubilee Ventures’ "guests" via AirBnB are NOT genuine “tenants”.

They are held no more than “commercial lodgers” whose presences violate Declaration’s prohibition of commercial activity despite a reported lack of short term strata accommodation by-law.

Adjudicator rejects operators’ defence claiming the usages are genuine residential tenancies of more than 30 days in term certain and allegedly compliant with a municipal license obtained for such.

Less attention looks paid to typical evidentiary crossclaims - eg about duration disputes / alleged back-dating & actual guest stays - than to several Tribunal decisions and to BCCA BC's court of Appeal itself defining such actual unit usages ( in HighStreet Accommodations 2019 which itself cites ground-breaking 2016 Menzies decision by Ottawa Justice Beaudoin ) as one of licensee or permittee, NOT of GENUINE “RESIDENTIAL TENANCY”.

So despite the 30 + day & tenancy claims, the group's "guesting" is ruled non-compliant commerce, not compliant residential tenancy. One thinks inn-keeping type stuff . . .
xcrpt “... 30. Based on the evidence, I find that the strata has proved that the people using the strata lots are not tenants but are temporary lodgers.

. . . I find the Jiwas are in violation of the bylaws because they have been providing their strata lots as temporary lodgings for a fee and not as a private dwelling unit in violation of the bylaws.” -unquote

The Owners, Strata Plan VR 245 v. Jiwa et al , 2020 BCCRT 775 issued July 10/20

July 18/20 CBC “Vancouver strata wins 5-year battle against Airbnb operator” by Maryse Zeidler
  The administrator has disabled public write access.
contact webmaster